Just what motivates
someone to risk their life as a drug courier through South East Asia,
and what is life like for them when imprisoned a long way from home?
With nine Australians facing drug charges in Indonesia, and Schapelle
Corby’s trial continuing, Ari Sharp tells of meeting some of the
foreigners detained at Thailand’s notorious Bangkwang Prison.
Lazing around at a backpacker hostel in the
Khao San district of Bangkok, I came across
the following
on the notice board:
VISITING
BANGKWANG, KLONG PREM and other prisons
It is usually possible to go and visit a prisoner without prior notice.
These visits allow the visitor to have a conversation with only a fence,
(or two fences as at Bangkwang) between yourself the prisoner.
Keen to see a very
different side to Bangkok, this was an invitation too intriguing to pass
up.
Dutifully, I followed the straightforward instructions that led me to
the river, on a thirty minute river express boat ride up to Nonthaburi,
in the poverty-riddled northern part of Bangkok, and then for a brief
walk to the prison grounds.
I had to photocopy my passport, obtain a visitors’ slip and nominate the
prisoner I was there to visit. At the hostel I had read a little about
Jagnathan Samynathan, a Malaysian national imprisoned at Bangkwang. I
put his name on the form.
In the visiting centre, prisoners and visitors satalong long benches,
facing wire and bars with a metre gap separating the prisoners' fence
from the visitors' fence. The distance and the noise made it trying and
frustrating, but the prisoners were used to the inconvenience and
carried on regardless. On the wall in both English and Thai was a
warning:anyone caught trying to organise narcotic sales would be given
the death penalty. And have a nice day.
Finally I met Jagnathan, or Jag as he soon became. Jag was an amazingly
warm and friendly man, talking at ease about some horrendous and
soul-destroying experiences. Piece by piece he revealed his story. A
committed Christian in his late 30s, Jag came from the Mallaca province
in Malaysia. When his shipping business was struggling in 1991, he
headed to Bangkok to try to make some quick cash as a drug courier. But
the authorities soon caught the drug syndicate, whose members implicated
Jag under interrogation, and he was arrested. Jag didn’t speak Thai but
the government assigned him a lawyer who spoke no English. His options
were limited: plead guilty and accept a life sentence which might be
commuted to a lengthy stay, or to plead not guilty and risk the death
penalty, which might be commuted to life in prison, with little hope of
any shorter sentence. He chose to fight the charges, and lost.
When we met, Jag had spent 14 years on the inside of Bangkwang prison.
In 1996, at the 50th anniversary of the King's coronation, his death
penalty was commuted to life in prison: a change which meant he no
longer needed to wear shackles on his legs 24 hours a day. He had seen
many prisoners come into Bangkwang, but few leave. Overcrowding was rife
at the prison, and up to 8,000 prisoners were held there, clearly beyond
its capacity. Jag said he slept on the cold floor in a room with 25
others, with no bedding at all. If they were enterprising enough they
could make a small blanket, no larger than the size of a pillow case.
As we were talking,
some other prisoners walked by and stopped for a chat, including a
couple of British prisoners imprisoned for drug offences. Their names
were Andrew Hawke, Michael Connell and Lee James William. All were
remarkably stoic and accepting of their plight, and their guilt, but
believed they deserved a second chance. There was no sense of self-pity
or desperate longing for the outside world. To keep morale high, the
four joked with each other, thick British accents seeming out of place.
They muttered about the silliness of the prison bureaucracy and its
obscure rules and decisions, and voiced a general consensus that the
medical care was inadequate. One prisoner was told he was lying about
his injured leg and so denied assistance, was Jag avoids the pain of his
peptic ulcers through his own crude treatment - he avoids eating
anything .
I had a mental
stereotype of the typical prisoner, and this stereotype is only more
exaggerated for those in a foreign prison. I expected world-weary
people, showing the physical and emotional scars of time on the inside
and holding a high level of cynicism about the outside world. To my
mind, it was hardened wrongdoers who found they way into prison, knowing
of little else. But I found this stereotype was proved wrong: the
prisoners I met were fundamentally good blokes, who for their own
regrettable reasons did wrong. They were worldly, intelligent, well-read
and hopeful about having a decent future. Easy as it would be to dismiss
them as fools or worse, they were not the dregs of society but instead
the wrong people in the wrong circumstances.
Jag he believed he had an especially tough time because of his
nationality. As a Christian from the predominantly Muslim nation of
Malaysia, he believed his government was not prepared to fight for his
release or his transfer home. Also because of his nationality, he
believed he didn’t receive as many visitors as the other foreign
prisoners did: many the European missionaries and British travellers
were keen to comfort “one of their own”. Jag had used his time inside
productively, and had learnt Thai, perfected English, and was attempting
Spanish (to go with his Malay and Tamil from before he entered) as well
as learning to play the guitar. Jag was arming himself for life on the
outside, although sadly this seemed to be a long way off. Jag was
hopeful that the 60th anniversary of the royal coronation
in
2006 might result in a pardon for himself and some other prisoners.
Finally the bells rang and it was time to leave the visitors centre.
Tearful farewells were exchanged amongst both the Thai families there to
visit their loved ones and the foreign visitors there to make contact
with new friends. The tears were all from those outside the prison - for
those inside it was just another grinding day, and just another farewell
until the next visit punctuated the monotony of life behind bars.
Bangkwang Prison exemplifies a dark and sinister side to Bangkok, which
few visitors get to see. The stories from those on the inside haunt
anyone who hears them, and this is perhaps the closest thing to a living
hell. Difficult conditions, no one who cares and no hope of release. The
harsh treatment meted out to drug offenders is justified by the apparent
success at curbing the drug trade out of Asia’s “Golden Triangle”. The
price of this deterrent, though, is the pit of human misery that is
Bangkwang Prison. Is it a price worth paying? As I headed back to the
relative opulence of downtown Bangkok, I seriously doubted it.
Ari Sharp is a student
and writer from Melbourne. He has written more about his travel through
Asia at his blog
www.ariontheweb.blogspot.com.